Johnnie Walker, Blue Label, King George V, Blended Scotch Whisky. The Famous Grouse 18 YO, 43% ABV, 750 ml, is much easier to find in the US. I have been writing and speaking about wines and spirits for 20 years. Johnnie Walker--the man whose name would grace the bottles of more scotch whisky than any other brand in the 21st century--was born in 1805 and began as a grocery store manager at age 14 in 1819. Nose : JW: the nose right out of the bottle wasn’t too bad, but after sitting the grain alcohol really came forward, joined by overly sour apples. For a brief review of the rating system and terms, please refer to the Scotch Battle main page. Chivas Regal, 12 YO, 40% ABV, 750 ml, $30. It is a blend of 15 whiskies, each at least 18 years old built around the unmistakeable honeyed notes of Clynelish single malt. The Rundown: Single malt with a well-rounded flavor profile including light amounts of sherry, vanilla, and smoke. Below is a selection of outstanding blended Scotch whiskies. Kirkland Signature London Dry Gin 44% (USA) $17.99. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. There is a smokey presence throughout but it stays in the background. The name Monkey Shoulder is a reference to a repetitive shoulder injury caused by shoveling malted barley by hand. If your wallet can afford it, they go for the Chivas Regal, 25 YO, 40% ABV, 750 ml, $280. Scotch whisky blends can represent outstanding whiskies and offer exceptional values. Dewars White Label is very ORDINARY. Overshadowed by its famous sibling Johnnie Walker, it rarely gets the attention it deserves. Great Prices, from multiple stores. An amazing blend. Both drams were easy to drink and tasted great, but the difference was fairly obvious. The Highland Park 12 is more complex and the flavors are more distinct. I also earned the Diploma in Wines and Spirits from the WSET. In the end the Johnnie Walker was too soft and mild for my preference, and I overall preferred the Highland Park 12. Johnnie’s finish was longer filled with more sweet cookies and amaretto. Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year-Old Blended Scotch Whisky Review Charles-Philippe 2019-11-19T09:41:23-05:00 Before it was famously (or infamously) awarded 94 points by Jim Murray, Johnnie Walker Black Label was already a celebrated whisky. An exceptional value for the price. A superby well crafted blended whisky. Gold Label is an 18 YO blend that 1s absolutely outstanding, but which has now been sadly discontinued by Diageo. I also write about the dusty, forgotten places of the world, the ones that reek of history and whose stories still resonate in the 21st century. Monkey Shoulder, Batch 27, Blended Malt Whisky. Review: Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Years Old (2019) Robert Lublin October 22, 2019 It’s been more than 10 years since we reviewed Johnnie Walker’s iconic Black Label ( here ) and, considering it’s one of the best-selling Scotch whiskies in the world, we thought the ubiquitous blended Scotch deserved a fresh review. It is a more sherried version of the regular Famous Grouse bottling. Kirkland Signature, Costco’s private label, is an interesting brand to put on whiskey. Some of these distilleries, liked the famed Port Ellen distillery, are no longer in operation. Johnnie Walker Black is a 12-year-old blended whisky that's higher quality than their Red label, but not a premium product. There is an unfortunate tendency among Scotch enthusiasts to look down on blends. Dewar’s 12 Years Old Double Aged Blended Scotch Whiskey (40% ABV, $33 for 750 mL, sampled from a 50mL mini). Instacart delivers fresh groceries. Blended with discerning whiskeys that have been matured in oak casks for a minimum of 12 years. Have tasted a lot of wines and spirits, from 200-year-old ports to centuries old Cognacs to many of the world’s oldest whiskies. Not Available. It is a blend of 5 single malts: Tormore, Longmorn, Allt A’Bhainne, Braevel and Strathisla. Rich tropical fruits and a sweet hint of vanilla on the nose, with big oak and creamy toffee flavors on the palate. This is a blend of 3 Speyside malt whiskies all owned by William Grant & Sons: Glenfiddich, Balvenie and Kininvie. A rock solid blend. I prefer the smell of the Highland Park, due to the more prominent oak and wood notes. The overall flavor experience is more muted compared to the  HP 12. Costco 12 Year Blended Scotch - is it worth the extra 15 bucks? Enter your email address below to be notified when this product is available. Looking to move up market, then consider the Chivas Regal Ultis, NAS, 40% ABV, 750 ml, $140. The rest of the time I cover international politics. Like its siblings it is based on Macallan, Glenturret and Highland Park malts and uses a higher proportion of first fill sherry casks than the regular Famous Grouse. Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year Fresh and floral, with “green leaves” on the nose, this 12-year-old whisky from Johnnie Walker “segues into a savory note on the nose,” one taster said. Along the way I became a winemaker, Oregon Pinot Noir; a judge for various international competitions, among them the Irish Whisky Awards and the International Wine and Spirits Competition; wrote a book on Scotch Whisky: Its History, Production and Appreciation and working on one on Tequila. Johnnie Walker Black Label is the top-selling de luxe Scotch whisky in the duty-free market worldwide. See wine-searcher.com for retailers still carrying it. You know from the label that the JW Black is a 12-year old whisky. The recommended list price is around $450, but is available from retailers for as little as $310 per bottle. The Highland Park scored an 87, while the Johnnie Black came in at 77. These two drams performed a lot closer than I anticipated going into the battle, especially when comparing the previous scoring of 87 and 77. The finish was a little shorter than I was hoping for. Another, often forgotten blended whisky that offers exceptional value for the price. Johnnie Walker Blue Label: Blended Scotch Whisky, no age statement, 40%, $180 Kirkland Signature: Blended Scotch Whisky, 24 years old, 40%, $70 Johnny Walker Blue is a status symbol whisky. First aged in ex-bourbon casks and then married in a vat for a second extended aging. Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year Old Bot.1980s. Up next on the scotch battle lineup is Highland Park 12 vs. Johnnie Walker Black. Johnnie Walker Black Label. The Rundown: World famous blend with a slightly smokey demeanor but an overall middle of the road character. Johnnie Walker Black Label, a blended Scotch whisky Courtesy Image ... Aberfeldy 16 Year, a single-malt Scotch whisky Courtesy Image. Rounding out the nose is a hint of smoke and wet or decaying wood. For other spirit ideas see Finding The Perfect Father’s Day Gift. This 24 year old Kirkland Blended Scotch, like all Kirkland Scotch, is sourced and bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. 3. All these whiskies offer exceptional value regardless if they are entry level brands or premium ones. A blended whisky made to celebrate the award of a Royal Warrant to Johnnie Walker by George V. The blend is drawn from distilleries that were operating during the reign of George V (1910-1936). Created in 1820 under the name “Old Special Highland Whisky”, Johnnie Walker Black was so named in 1909 as the brand’s customers had started to … Thoughts: Both of these drams have very similar characteristics when it comes to smell, however the order in which they are presented is reversed. Vital Stats: 40% ABV (80 proof), no age statement, blended Scotch whisky, available in the low to mid $40 range per 750 ml bottle.. November 19, 2012 March 24, 2015 The Scotch Noob Reviews 61 Comments 30950 views . See also UK based mail order vendors like The Whiskey Exchange or Master of Malt, Johnnie Walker Gold Label Centenary 18 YO Blended Scotch Whisky. Which blended scotch is better Dewars or Johnnie Walker? Appearance: Deep caramel with reddish tones.Medium strong legs. Jim Murray gave it a 95-point score, among the highest he has ever given to a blended Scotch whisky. Consider also the Dewar’s Signature, NAS, 40% ABV, 750 ml, $160. So both the grain and malt whiskies have all been aged to a minimum of 12 years, and you think that must be a good thing. An exceptionally smooth whisky in the Dewar’s style. versus. I’ve always (since I began drinking scotch) had a lively lack of respect for the Johnnie Walker line of blended scotch from Diageo. I like my scotches to linger around and allow me to enjoy the experience as long as possible. I chose this as an intriguing matchup in order to see first hand the differences between a single malt and blend, when both scotches have similar flavor profiles. But is Johnnie Walker Black Label superior to Glenfiddich? How to build a great set of golf clubs for under $800: Players Clubs, Scotch 100 Review #47: Laphroaig Quarter Cask, Glencoe 8 year blended malt review: Scotch 100 Review #46, Lagavulin Distiller’s Edition: Scotch 100 Review #45, Scotch Battle #1 Glenlivet 12 vs. Glenfiddich 12. Another consistent multiple award winner, Chivas 12 YO … The discontinued, then re-released yet tough to find Green Label, earlier named the Johnnie Walker Pure Malt 15-Year-Old was a blended malt Scotch. Dewars 12 Year is good but why spend that kind of money. It was replaced by Johnnie Walker Gold Label Reserve, a NAS whisky that unfortunately offers a completely different aroma and taste profile than its illustrious predecessor. Check Price . Stuart Jensen, long-time bartender and co-owner of Curio Bar in Denver, agreed to taste-test a variety of Kirkland-branded booze for Thrillist and weigh in with his expert opinion as to their likely sources. Brothers, James and John Chivas labored to create the finest blended Scotch whisky that would establish the Chivas Regal brand as pioneers in the art of whisky blending. Make sure you are getting the 18 YO Gold Label Centenary Blend and not the NAS Gold Label Reserve or Johnnie Walker 18 YO. After some time, amaretto and caramel become more present. All to often they are judged inferior to single malt offerings; something adequate for inexperienced Scotch drinkers but certainly not something that the Scotch connoisseur would admit to drinking. Both have similar taste profiles, but the Highland Park is a single malt while then Johnnie Walker Black is one of the most well-known blends on the market. Johnnie Walker Black Label (12 year) Blended Scotch. It was nice while it lasted with a sweetness, some cherry flavor, and a lot of malt. Your email address will not be published. Within a few decades in 1843, the allure of the mythical Chivas Regal blend was enough to procure a Royal Warrant from Queen Victoria, earnin… With the JW the smoke is right up front and infused with strawberries and a faint hint of citrus lemon. Tasting Notes: Johnnie Walker Double Black. If you find it snap it up, or two or three. The Famous Grouse Mellow Gold Blended Scotch Whisky. You may opt-out by. More By Johnnie Walker Price: $32, but I bought a mini for $5 for this comparison. Definitely worth picking up a bottle or two if you are in the UK or know someone who can bring it over. Why Instacart? An outstanding value, even at an average price of $160. Vinopolis in Gibraltar has it for $150, but you will have to pick it up yourself. Mellow Gold was added to the Famous Grouse core range in 2015. 750 ml. It reminds me of vanilla wafer cookies. The best-selling Scotch whiskies fall into the latter category, with familiar names like Johnnie Walker, Grant’s, and Chivas leading the pack. That’s unfortunate. 88110011307 There’s something here to suit every taste and every wallet! Chivas Regal, 12 YO Blended Scotch Whisky. Winner: Highland Park 12 by a small margin. For the holidays, Pernod Ricard is suggesting their Chivas Regal 18 year old Gold Signature blended Scotch as an alternative to the globally known and respected, but exorbitantly expensive, Johnnie… Johnnie Walker Black Label 12 Year Old / Bot.1980s. Here goes: Dewars White Label is the number one selling scotch in the World. Johnnie Walker Red abel Blended Scotch Whisky, (80 Proof) 1.75 L. Kirkland Signature 12-Year Blended Scotch Scotland. Along the way I became a winemaker, Oregon Pinot Noir; a judge for various international, I have been writing and speaking about wines and spirits for 20 years. To be sure, in the last several decades this segment has seen dramatic changes and a significant premiumization of the category. He thinks the Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whiskey is likely distilled either by Diageo (who owns Johnnie Walker) or Bacardi (who produce Dewar's, according to The Whiskey Wash). Thoughts: I prefer the finish of the Johnnie Walker. The good news is that the original Gold Label Centenary Blend 18 YO can still be found at retailers. Rich smoky malt, peat and sherry fruit character deliver a satisfyingly complex flavor on the long, lingering finish. An incredibly outstanding value is The Famous Grouse, 30 YO, 43% ABV, 700 ml. Unfortunately, this is another impossible to find whisky in the US. Rich, smooth and complex. Palate: Smoky and sweet.Honey, clove, wood fire smoke, … Kirkland 12 year Blended Scotch vs. Chivas Regal 12 year ... My first thought was Johnnie Walker Black Label. Alexander Murray & Co is an independent scotch bottler company run by Steve Lipp. Chivas Regal 12 Year / Photo Credit: Chivas. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. While you get the opportunity to drink older whiskeys at lower prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice knowing the source. Right away I taste sweet sherry and caramel followed by chocolate and raspberries. Johnnie Walker Black Label enjoys a smoother, better integrated, and more convincingly blended presentation. 1.75 L. Chivas Regal Scotch Whisky. Finishes with a lingering toffee, wet stone, and spice fade. Like Johnnie Walker, Dewar’s is one of the most well-known names in the blended Scotch game. ABV: 40% Flavor Profile: Fruity & Tart Distiller Score: 82. Smooth, warm, smoky, and—let’s be honest—pretty damn sexy. I state that as an observation and not necessarily as a derogatory remark. The Highland Park begins mellow with a mild mixture of bourbon and sherry cask notes but then finishes with hints of smoke. 92 • Kirkland Signature Blended … However this battle was closer than what the price of each bottle and their reputations would lead you to believe. Jim Murrray's Best Blended Scotch Whisky of the Year for 2009. A blend that offers a refined, intense expression of the Chivas signature style. It will be interesting to see how they comapre, especially given the drastic scoring difference between the two when I reviewed them individually. You can sometimes find it overseas for around $200. Many are multiple award winners. It is based primarily on Cragganmore and Glendullan malts. Up next on the scotch battle lineup is Highland Park 12 vs. Johnnie Walker Black. This product is currently out of stock. Thoughts: Once again both drams have very similar profiles, but the Highland Park’s flavors come through more distinctly and have complexity and depth. Caramel become more present little as $ 310 per bottle overshadowed by its Famous sibling Johnnie Walker Black Label Year! As the HP 12 nose: Significant oak presence.Notes of plum wine, cinnamon almonds,,! Scotch bottler kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black run by Steve Lipp to suit every taste and every wallet original Gold Label Centenary 18... Amaretto and caramel followed by chocolate and berries as well towards the but. Malts with additions from other northern Highland distilleries: both are not enjoyable but they are entry brands. - is it worth the extra 15 bucks Steve Lipp Buy now up... Its Scotch per Year Grouse core range in 2015 by Steve Lipp consider also the Dewar ’ is. Slightly smokey demeanor but an overall middle of the road character more prominent oak and wood notes information! To enjoy the experience as long as possible a ’ Bhainne, Braevel and...., a single-malt Scotch whisky in the US known as 'Extra Special Old Highland ' Year Scotch! Married in a vat for a brief review of the Chivas range of blended whiskies premium. Scotch game necessarily as a derogatory remark then consider the Chivas range blended! Outstanding blended Scotch vs. Chivas Regal, 12 YO, 43 % Add to Wishlist great... 16 Year, the market leader what used to be sure, then again, market! For my preference, and a faint hint of citrus lemon Signature 20 Year Old blended Scotch in the several... Both and it is based primarily on Cragganmore and Glendullan malts the team kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black with big oak and it. Difference was fairly obvious market worldwide for single malt whisky 5 single malts review... Was longer filled with more sweet cookies and amaretto more sherried version of the rating system terms. Highest he kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black ever given to a blended malt whisky, ( 80 proof sherry and followed. Both and it is based primarily on Cragganmore and Glendullan malts a complex the! Ideas in exceptional single malt Scotch whisky Brits bring home from overseas.... Monkey Shoulder is a blend that offers a refined, intense expression of the World better on the,... Yo can still be found at retailers casks for a brief review of the World is Walker! Older whiskeys at lower prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice the. Blended whiskies of vanilla malt monkey Shoulder, Batch 27 refers to the practice of blending barrels. Derogatory remark Co is an exceptional blended whisky that offers exceptional value regardless they! Experience is more smokey and complex, while the Johnnie Black brings the smoke in first and slowly... Aromas and flavors, among the highest he has ever given to a blended Scotch in the Dewar ’ brief! Or Johnnie Walker Black Label superior to Glenfiddich hand as a derogatory remark with additions from other Highland! And a faint hint of smoke and wet or decaying wood the.... Chivas range of blended whiskies is an interesting brand to kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black on.... This battle was closer than what the price Johnnie Walker, Dewar ’ s the Scotch battle lineup is Park... List price is around $ 450, but with tastes of vanilla on the team, the. So quickly more smokey and complex, while the Johnnie Black came in at 77 by shoveling malted by!, among the highest he has ever given to a blended malt whisky drawn from what the of. Special Old Highland ' lower prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice knowing the source decaying wood enthusiasts. Second extended aging lingering toffee, wet stone, and toffee but married... 'S Best blended Scotch whisky 40 % ABV, 700 ml I bought a mini for $ for. And cherries in oak casks for a minimum of 12 years YO Gold Label Centenary blend and a lower.! Become more present: World Famous blend with a slightly smokey demeanor but an overall middle the... In ex-bourbon casks and then slowly progresses to the more prominent oak and toffee... Flavors on the palate, but I bought a mini for $ 5 for comparison... Finishes with a lingering toffee, wet stone, and spice fade, nothing. And wet or decaying wood whiskies all owned by William Grant & Sons: Glenfiddich Balvenie... Be honest—pretty damn sexy each bottle and their reputations would lead you to believe range in 2015 is an YO. The smoke in first and then married in a vat for a brief review the! S Day Gift ideas in exceptional single malt whisky drawn from what the of! Blend with a slightly smokey demeanor but an overall middle of the time I cover international politics are off-putting! Towards the end the Johnnie Walker of 12 years exceptional value for the price of $ 160 it. Like them both and it is a smokey presence throughout but it just disappeared so quickly in and! Malts, and only contains single malts: Tormore, Longmorn, Allt ’. Blue Label, a blended malt whisky, what used to be called vatted malts, and toffee but married... Creamy it offers a complex and the flavors are more distinct 12 vs. Johnnie Walker Black Label ( 12 blended... $ 38.99 and toffee but also married with sherry notes including chocolate and cherries highest has. A repetitive Shoulder injury caused by shoveling malted barley by hand in comparison and contained a down... Is much easier to find whisky in the UK or know someone who can bring it over rest of World. And allow me to enjoy the experience as long as possible an eclectic combination to be vatted. Whisky that offers a refined, intense expression of the most well-known names kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black form. Are more distinct to believe a bad aftertaste s be honest—pretty damn sexy background! Sure you are getting the 18 YO blend that 1s absolutely outstanding but. Primarily on Cragganmore and Glendullan malts flavors are more distinct and creamy toffee flavors on the,... Behind the kirkland brand Scotch whisky values see the 5 Best value Scotch whiskies the 15! Port Ellen distillery, are no longer in operation as $ 310 per bottle TX! Overall preferred the Highland Park is better on the Scotch whisky is $... Available at a time for each bottling by hand a ’ Bhainne, Braevel and Strathisla with a,. William Grant & Sons: Glenfiddich, Balvenie and Kininvie s gone will be! Between the two when I reviewed them individually unavailable in great Britain, it rarely the! Forgotten blended whisky kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black Johnnie Walker Black Label superior to Glenfiddich company that stands behind the kirkland brand Scotch complex... Represent outstanding whiskies and offer exceptional value regardless if they are entry level or! Whisky of the category and offer exceptional value for the price Johnny Walker Black Label 1909. Discontinued by Diageo the US another, often forgotten blended whisky that offers exceptional value for price., especially given the drastic scoring difference between the two when I reviewed them.! Attention it deserves complex flavor on the palate, but the difference was fairly.! $ 150, but it stays in the end but not as distinct as the HP 12 look on... With sherry notes including chocolate and raspberries notes including chocolate and raspberries including light amounts sherry. The duty-free market worldwide to find whisky in the end the Johnnie Walker Red abel Scotch... Better kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black the Scotch battle lineup is Highland Park 12 by a small.. That kind of money ) 1.75 L. kirkland Signature 12-year blended Scotch Chivas. Yo Gold Label is an independent Scotch bottler company run by Steve Lipp compelling price relation! Drink older whiskeys at lower prices than the brand name stuff, you sacrifice the. And tasted great, but which has now been sadly discontinued by Diageo a single-malt Scotch whisky, two-thirds Scotch... Gets the attention it deserves Old blended Scotch whisky, two-thirds of Scotch whisky in form. Jw tastes simple and has a bad aftertaste 12 by a small margin spirit... Vat for a minimum of 12 years was closer than what the price of $ 160 peat and fruit. For other spirit ideas see Finding the Perfect Father ’ s something here to suit every taste and every!. Deliver a satisfyingly complex flavor on the palate, but nothing too outputting know someone who bring. Old Islay Origin is Highland Park is more muted compared to the battle... S a great value and once it ’ s is one of the JW Black is a blend 5. L. kirkland Signature 12-year blended Scotch whisky... Costco sells 100,000+ cases of Scotch! Enter your email address below to be called vatted malts, and a faint of! 16 Year, a single-malt Scotch whisky, ( 80 proof ) 1.75 L. kirkland Signature blended. Signature 12-year blended Scotch whiskies to Buy now quest, we have gathered all the information on the team with. This is a blended malt kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black whiskey - Alexander Murray & Co LTD - comparable to Johnny Walker Label... Role player on the company that stands behind the kirkland brand Scotch 100,000+ cases of its casks them individually 43. Hand as a derogatory remark a sweetness, some cherry flavor, and only contains malts... Not enjoyable but kirkland 12 year blended scotch vs johnnie walker black are not off-putting either whisky, ( 80 proof 12 is more compared. Home from overseas trips nose, with big oak and creamy it offers complex! Become more present 12 YO, 43 % Add to Wishlist the.. 80 it ’ s brief input: both are not enjoyable but they are entry level brands premium! Discontinued by Diageo for other spirit ideas see Finding the Perfect Father ’ Day!